| Doug DuBois, Jr., 2022 |
| Spence Collins, 2021 |
| Steve Fenoglio, 2020 |
| Not awarded, 2019 |
| Alan McGraw, 2018 |
| Doug DuBois, Jr., 2017 |
| Rick Prekup, 2016 |
| Tom Hewitt, 2015 |
| Steele Zinser, 2014 |
| Kevin McConnell, 2013 |
| John Bryan, 2012 |
| Bill Bebee, 2011 |
| Corey Gaskill, 2010 |
| Patrick Mullin, 2009 |
| |
| Doug DuBois, Jr., 2008 |
| Jimmy Cobb, 2007 |
| Terry Meyers, 2006 |
| Kent Brenneman, 2005 |
| Roland Krienke, 2003 |
| David Conrad, 2002 |
| Joe Bob Everett, 2001 |
| Steve Ray, 2000 |
| Tom Bergstrom, 1999 |
| Don Lanford, 1998 |
| Carl Young, 1997 |
| Jim Shipwash, 1996 |
| Sam Wilson, 1995 |
| Horace Gore, 1994 |
| |
| Joe Colbert, 1993 |
| Robert Johnson, 1992 |
| W.R. "Bill" Williamson, 1991 |
| John Alford, 1990 |
| John Jefferson, 1989 |
| Emory Thompson, 1988 |
| Jimmy L. Barho, 1987 |
| Arvin Harrell, 1986 |
| William O. Dudley, 1985 |
| Marshall Kuykendall, 1984 |
| Charlie Schnabel, 1983 |
| Jim Adamson, 1982 |
| W.C. "Bill" Ebert, 1981 |
| Jerry Reed, 1980 |
| |
| Ed Fleming, Jr., 1979 |
| Cecil Reid, 1978 |
| Harry Montandon, 1977 |
| Bud Dryden, 1976 |
| Joe McBride, 1975 |
| L.A. Wilke, 1974 |
| "Stocke" Stockebrand, 1973 |
| Bob Singleton, 1972 |
| E.E. Steussy, 1971 |
| George Bolton, 1970 |
| Robert P. Landes, 1969 |
| John Barclay, 1968 |
| Herman Neusch, 1967 |
| Joe Lanham, 1966 |
|
